Homeland – Showtime – 10/2/11
Homeland stars Claire Daines as a CIA analyst who obtains a piece of intelligence about terrorist activity that no one else knows, which is that an American prisoner of war has been turned by Al Queda. She makes nothing of that information until a POW marine who has been away eight years is discovered alive in Iraq. Hailed as an American hero, the POW, played by Damian Lewis, may be a terrorist, or Daines may be crazy. Nothing but great buzz here, and it sounds more intriguing than any other new show as a layered psychological thriller.
Prediction: Renewal – best buzz of the year, and that’s worth even more on a premium network, and even more on Showtime, which still wants to be HBO
American Horror Story – FX – 10/5/11
The preview looks insane, and about the only fact I know, other than that Dylan McDermott and Connie Britton and their kid move into a haunted house is that Britton has sex with a ghost in a latex suit in the first episode, and frankly that leaves me even more confused. Ryan Murphy has an extremely hit and miss record (Nip/Tuck, Glee) and horror is a genre that you generally don’t see on television, because it doesn’t play well for the long run. From what buzz I have read, a ton takes place in the first episode, enough to make the episode exciting in and of itself but to wonder where the show goes from there, and why the fuck the couple doesn’t just move out. This’ll probably take a couple episodes of watching to figure out whether it’s worthwhile.
Prediction: Renewal – I honestly don’t know what to think, but here’s a stab
Hell on Wheels – 11/6/11
Set during the building of the transcontinental railroad, the series features a confederate soldier determined to take revenge on union soldiers who murdered his wife. Deadwood is the first comparison that springs to mind, due to the time period. It looks at least interesting, and as a history major, I tend to be a sucker for historically-based shows. Apparently reconstruction plays a part, and Native American attacks, and who knows what else.
Prediction: Renewal – I have just as little idea as with the show above, but since Rubicon’s been the only non-Renewed show on AMC so far, I’ll take the odds
Boss – Starz – 10/21/11
Kelsey Grammer stars as the mayor of Chicago who has been recently diagnosed with a degenerative neurological disease. He keeps this from everyone, his family, friends and staff, who are generally too busy with their own priorities to notice him slipping. Political intrigue and family drama are in play, with administration members shooting for higher office, and a relationship between Grammar and his wife that may be falling apart. I’m not sure it will be good, but it certainly could be.
Verdict: Renewal – this is downright cheating – it’s already been renewed, which is admittedly kind of incredible. I wish Party Down got this kind of support from Starz.
Enlightened – HBO – 9/10/11
Laura Dern portrays an executive with a public breakdown in this HBO comedy. Buzz seems to be at least slightly positive. Luke Wilson plays her ex-husband, and Diane Ladd playes her mother. Creator Mike White wrote for Freaks and Geeks and wrote School of Rock, but also wrote Nacho Libre. This preview is admittedly weak but after the varying and distinct dramatic premises of the shows above, it’s hard to find a lot to say about Enlightened, especially before watching it. I don’t mean that in a bad way, just in a premise-is-a-lot-less-important-in-comedy-so-let’s-wait-and-see way.
Prediction: Renewal – it’s absolutely ridiculous I’ve predicted renewal for all of these, though I feel anecdotally shows are more likely to get picked up on premium cable networks.