(Power Rankings sum up: Each week, we’ll pick a television show and rank the actors/actresses/contestants/correspondents/etc. based on what they’ve done after the series ended (unless we’re ranking a current series, in which case we’ll have to bend the rules). Preference will be given to more recent work, but if the work was a long time ago, but much more important/relevant, that will be factored in as well)
Buffy the Vampire Slayer power rankings this week. We’re covering a lot of actors and actresses who have been in the cast over the seven seasons of the show, but we had to draw an episode cut off line somewhere. Apologies Eliza Dushku and Mark Blucas. That said, it’s a fairly impressive bunch.
11. Amber Benson (as Tara Maclay) – She’s mostly been in a series of indie films and single episode appearances of shows such as Cold Case, The Inside, Private Practice, Grey’s Anatomy and Supernatural. She’s also written a handful of books with Christopher Golden.
10. Emma Caulfield (as Anya) – She appeared in a Monk episode and in a couple of Robot Chickens as well as a Private Practice. She was a recurring character in one-season TeenNick show Gigantic and in 11 episodes of CW two season show Life Unexpected.
9. Charisma Carpenter (as Cordelia Chase) – She moved over to Angel along with David Boreanaz. After her role there ended, she appeared in four episodes of Miss Match and episodes of The Division, Charmed, LAX, Big Shots and Back to You. She was a recurring character as Kendall Casablancas in 11 episodes of Veronica Mars. She’s also appeared in episodes of CSI: Crime Scene Investigation, Legend of the Seeker, Burn Notice and Supernatural, and in four episodes of ABC Family’s Greek. Last year she appeared in feature film The Expendables.
8. Nicholas Brandon (as Xander Harris) – After Buffy ended, he starred in short-lived Fox series Kitchen Confidential based on Anthony Bourdain’s book of the same name with Bradley Cooper and John Francis Daley. He voiced Huntsboy #89 (I have no idea what this means) in six episodes of animated program American Dragon: Jake Long. He plays a recurring character Kevin Lynch on CBS’s Criminal Minds, having appeared in 11 episodes. He appeared in TV movie Relative Chaos with Buffy co-star Charisma Carpenter and in four episodes of Private Practice last year playing a mentally disturbed man.
7. James Marsters (as Spike) – He moved over to Angel for a season after Buffy ended. He appeared in a supporting role in P.S. I Love You. He was in four episodes of Without A Trace. He appeared as villain Brainiac in 14 episodes of Smallville and as a recurring character in one season Syfy Battlestar Galactica prequel Caprica. He also appeared as Piccolo in the live action film adaptation Dragonball: Evolution and in three episodes of Torchwood. Most recently he appeared in episodes of Hawaii Five-0 and Supernatural.
6. Michelle Trachtenberg (as Dawn Summers) – An actress from an early age, after Buffy, she portrayed pop star Celeste in four episodes of Six Feet Under. She starred in the kids movie Ice Princess and guest starred in episodes of House M.D. and Law & Order: Criminal Intent. She appeared in 17 Again and as recurring character Georgina Sparks in 14 episodes of Gossip Girl. She starred in the one season hospital drama Mercy and was in four episodes of Weeds.
5. Sarah Michelle Gellar (as Buffy Summers) – Gellar’s career seemed on the rise as Buffy ended, but that momentum largely stalled after the series ended. She appeared in the second Scooby Doo movie Scooby Doo 2: Monsters Unleashed as Daphne (she had appeared in the same role in the first while Buffy was airing) which was a commercial success but a critical bomb. She also appeared in the first and second Grudge movies and Richard Kelly’s disappointing Donnie Darko follow up Southland Tales. She also appeared in six episodes of Robot Chicken and The Air That I Breathe. She’s now starring in the first season of CW series Ringer which got picked up for a full season’s worth of episodes.
4. Anthony Stewart Head (as Rupert Giles) – the oldest member of the Buffy cast by a good deal (closest is Marsters), Head did little in America but has been quite busy in his native Britain. He had a small role in Woody Allen’s Scoop and starred in the cult horror rock opera Repo! The Genetic Opera. He was a regular in British sketch show Little Britain and narrated Doctor Who documentary series Doctor Who Confidential. He co-starred in BBC series Merlin as Arthur’s father King Uther Pendragon and co-starred as the boss in the successful BBC series Free Agents and the unsuccessful American remake of the same name.
3. Alyson Hannigan (as Willow Rosenberg) – Best known outside of Buffy at the time for her role in the American Pie series of movies, she’ll be reprising her role as Michelle in 2012’s American Reunion. She appeared in Date Movie, but she’s best known for her ongoing role as one of five main cast members in CBS’s multi-camera sitcom smash How I Met Your Mother, currently in its 7th season. Hannigan plays Lily Aldrin, kindergarden teacher and wife of Jason Segal’s Marshall Erikssen.
2. Seth Green (as Oz) – Green left Buffy after the third season. He’s continued his voice role as Chris Griffin on Family Guy which continues to this day and created and contributed his voice to five seasons of Robot Chicken on Adult Swim, which is still airing. He guest-starred in in five episodes of That ‘70s Show, two of Will and Grace, and three of Entourage as an exaggerated version of himself. He starred in one season NBC sitcom Four Kings and appeared in two episodes of Grey’s Anatomy and three of Heroes. He’s contributed to various voice roles in American Dad!, Star Wars: The Clone Wars, The Cleveland Show, stop-motion Adult Swim series Titan Maximum and the Mass Effect series of video games. He’s also appeared in feature films The Italian Job, Without a Paddle, Sex Drive and Old Dogs.
1. David Boreanaz (as Angel) – Boreanz left Buffy after the third season and starred in spin off Angel as the same character in Los Angeles, which lasted five seasons and ended a year after Buffy. Like Hannigan, Boreanaz has essentially only done one major project since leaving the Buffy-verse, but like Hannigan’s, it’s a seriously big one. The year after Angel ended, in 2005, he started his ongoing role as FBI Special Agent Seeley Booth, one of the main two characters in Fox’s Bones. Bones has been extremely successful and its seventh season will premier this week.